Court to decide on Nov 22 Anwar's request for doctors' notes, toxicology report
Anwar - gov't wants him during a behind of bars forward of snap pollsMalaysia Chronicle
The High Court will confirm upon Nov 22 whether or not to allow Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahims invulnerability group entrance to doctors records as well as a toxicology inform formed upon a clinical hearing of a complainant by 3 government doctors.
In transparent rebuttal of United Nations discipline upon fair-trial conditions, Prime Minister Najib Razaks administration department has refused to allow Anwars lawyers entrance to pass documents, nonetheless a Federal Court after authorised him to apply for a documents as as well as when they became required during a trial.
The apex justice ruled a invulnerability could apply documents during a course of hearing (but not pre-trial)," Malaysiakini reported lead invulnerability warn Karpal Singh as saying.
"However, a justice has wide latitude, as well as a invulnerability has similar rights to do a case. Your lordship will be seen as sitting as well as doing zero about it if a counterclaim application is not authorised as law contingency prevail."
A rush job
The sodomy charges pressed against Anwar have been well-known not usually in Malaysia though all round a universe with most universe leaders condemning Prime Minister Najib Razak for pushing by a case notwithstanding a manifestly built nature of a accusations.
Rosmah as well as NajibAnwar was indicted of sodomising his former help Saiful Bukhari Azlan during a plush condominium in Kuala Lumpur in 2008 usually after he voiced his goal to make his parliamentary comeback. He has denied a charges as well as indicted Najib as well as his wife Rosmah Mansor of plotting a government swindling to derail his political career.
Najib primarily denied assembly Saiful though after certified to it, as well as it is revelation which it was usually after this assembly which Saiful lodged a military censure which led to Anwar's prosecution.
Of late, a hearing has taken larger urgency with Judge Mohd Zabidin Mohd Diah indicted of rushing by a case as Najib steps up his bid to put his physical condition political opposition during a behind of bars forward of snap general elections widely expected to be hold subsequent year.
Reports with unfavorable inform hold back
Over a past couple of days, Karpal as well as his group have been cross-examining Dr Razali Ibrahim, one of a 3 doctors during a Hospital Kuala Lumpur who examined a complainant upon June 28, 2008.
Solicitor-General Yusof ZainalRazali could not answer most of a questions as a complex physical hearing was done dual years ago as well as a healing inform tendered by a charge did not enclose full details, nor were a clinical records taken by a doctors during a tests attached.
Razali also refused to ask for his records as once he does so, under justice rules, a invulnerability would also be entitled to see them.
"We want to know a patient's history. It cannot usually be a two-liner as stated in a final healing report. Even a kindergarten child can tell a two-liner is not a minute report. Hence, a justice should provide us with a clinical records for us to prove as well as presumably plea a declare testimony," Karpal told a court.
Meanwhile, Dr Razali's sworn statement upon Thursday has already caught Saiful in a lie. According to a doctor, Saiful's rectum was "empty", nonetheless Saiful had testified he did not pass suit for dual days since of a sodomy.
Caught lying though charge insists nonessential
Nonetheless, a charge led by Solicitor-general II Mohd Yusof Zainal Abiden objec! ted, ins isting which a records could usually be given if Dr Razali requested to see them.
Defense warn Karpal SinghWhat is critical is a experts' evidence, as well as not a notes. The declare did not apply to see a clinical report. Furthermore, they had unsuccessful to show any element contradiction for them to act upon a hunch to oppose a declare testimony. Furthermore, a counterclaim cannot enforce a charge to do so, pronounced Yusof said.
Also in contention is a chemists inform which a charge had submitted to a justice though attaching a all-important toxicology inform which contains a minute breakdown of a tests done.
According to Karpal, a Federal Court had ruled which if a request is to be submitted as evidence, a total of it contingency be admitted. If a documents have been not certified in its total than a total chemist inform should be rejected, he added.
"The counterclaim is denied entrance to a toxicology report, though they want to admit a chemist report. We have been denied the right. Your Honour can't usually sit behind as well as not do anything about it," he said.
The High Court will confirm upon Nov 22 whether or not to allow Opposition Leader Anwar Ibrahims invulnerability group entrance to doctors records as well as a toxicology inform formed upon a clinical hearing of a complainant by 3 government doctors.
In transparent rebuttal of United Nations discipline upon fair-trial conditions, Prime Minister Najib Razaks administration department has refused to allow Anwars lawyers entrance to pass documents, nonetheless a Federal Court after authorised him to apply for a documents as as well as when they became required during a trial.
The apex justice ruled a invulnerability could apply documents during a course of hearing (but not pre-trial)," Malaysiakini reported lead invulnerability warn Karpal Singh as saying.
"However, a justice has wide latitude, as well as a invulnerability has similar rights to do a case. Your lordship will be seen as sitting as well as doing zero about it if a counterclaim application is not authorised as law contingency prevail."
A rush job
The sodomy charges pressed against Anwar have been well-known not usually in Malaysia though all round a universe with most universe leaders condemning Prime Minister Najib Razak for pushing by a case notwithstanding a manifestly built nature of a accusations.
Rosmah as well as NajibAnwar was indicted of sodomising his former help Saiful Bukhari Azlan during a plush condominium in Kuala Lumpur in 2008 usually after he voiced his goal to make his parliamentary comeback. He has denied a charges as well as indicted Najib as well as his wife Rosmah Mansor of plotting a government swindling to derail his political career.
Najib primarily denied assembly Saiful though after certified to it, as well as it is revelation which it was usually after this assembly which Saiful lodged a military censure which led to Anwar's prosecution.
Of late, a hearing has taken larger urgency with Judge Mohd Zabidin Mohd Diah indicted of rushing by a case as Najib steps up his bid to put his physical condition political opposition during a behind of bars forward of snap general elections widely expected to be hold subsequent year.
Reports with unfavorable inform hold back
Over a past couple of days, Karpal as well as his group have been cross-examining Dr Razali Ibrahim, one of a 3 doctors during a Hospital Kuala Lumpur who examined a complainant upon June 28, 2008.
Solicitor-General Yusof ZainalRazali could not answer most of a questions as a complex physical hearing was done dual years ago as well as a healing inform tendered by a charge did not enclose full details, nor were a clinical records taken by a doctors during a tests attached.
Razali also refused to ask for his records as once he does so, under justice rules, a invulnerability would also be entitled to see them.
"We want to know a patient's history. It cannot usually be a two-liner as stated in a final healing report. Even a kindergarten child can tell a two-liner is not a minute report. Hence, a justice should provide us with a clinical records for us to prove as well as presumably plea a declare testimony," Karpal told a court.
Meanwhile, Dr Razali's sworn statement upon Thursday has already caught Saiful in a lie. According to a doctor, Saiful's rectum was "empty", nonetheless Saiful had testified he did not pass suit for dual days since of a sodomy.
Caught lying though charge insists nonessential
Nonetheless, a charge led by Solicitor-general II Mohd Yusof Zainal Abiden objec! ted, ins isting which a records could usually be given if Dr Razali requested to see them.
Defense warn Karpal SinghWhat is critical is a experts' evidence, as well as not a notes. The declare did not apply to see a clinical report. Furthermore, they had unsuccessful to show any element contradiction for them to act upon a hunch to oppose a declare testimony. Furthermore, a counterclaim cannot enforce a charge to do so, pronounced Yusof said.
Also in contention is a chemists inform which a charge had submitted to a justice though attaching a all-important toxicology inform which contains a minute breakdown of a tests done.
According to Karpal, a Federal Court had ruled which if a request is to be submitted as evidence, a total of it contingency be admitted. If a documents have been not certified in its total than a total chemist inform should be rejected, he added.
"The counterclaim is denied entrance to a toxicology report, though they want to admit a chemist report. We have been denied the right. Your Honour can't usually sit behind as well as not do anything about it," he said.
Comments